Most owners frame this as a price question. Co-hosts are cheaper, managers do more, pick your trade-off.
The more useful question is who does the work a co-host doesn't. Cleaning crews, repairs, permits and tax filings still have to happen. They land on you, on a patchwork of vendors, or on a manager.
Below are real numbers on a Scottsdale home and the Arizona rules that usually settle it.
The Short Answer
Hire a co-host if you live nearby, you already have a cleaner and handyman you trust, and you mostly want help with messaging and pricing.
Hire a full-service manager if you live out of state, you own more than one property, or you don't want to be the person who gets the call when the AC dies in July.
Either way, read the fee structure closely. A cheap co-host who leaves you running operations can cost more in your time than a manager costs in fees, and a 30% manager has to earn that cut with higher revenue.
What an Airbnb Co-Host Actually Does
A co-host is someone you add to your Airbnb listing with permission to act on your behalf. Airbnb formalized this with its Co-Host Network, so you can now find and hire co-hosts right inside the app.
The scope varies a lot from person to person, but a typical co-host covers:
- Listing setup and copywriting
- Guest messaging and reviews
- Pricing and calendar management
- Coordinating (not doing) cleanings
- Sometimes check-in support or a quick property check
What they usually don't cover:
- Hiring, training and paying the cleaning crew
- Restocking supplies and linens
- Maintenance, repairs and vendor management
- Permits, license renewals and TPT filings
- Insurance, damage claims and guest disputes
- Listing on Vrbo, Booking.com or a direct-booking site
Some co-hosts run a full-time business with a local team. Others are hosts picking up a few extra listings on the side. Both can work. Ask which one you're talking to.
What a Full-Service Property Manager Does
A full-service manager runs the whole operation. Think of it as handing over the keys and getting a monthly statement.
That typically includes everything a co-host does, plus cleaning and turnover, maintenance and emergencies, restocking, multi-platform listings, owner reporting, and the compliance paperwork.
The catch is price. Most full-service managers charge 20-35% of gross booking revenue, and plenty of them add setup fees, maintenance markups or a cut of the cleaning fee on top. Read the agreement line by line.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Airbnb Co-Host | Full-Service Manager | |
|---|---|---|
| Typical fee | 10-20% of payout | 20-35% of gross bookings |
| Guest messaging | Yes | Yes |
| Pricing and calendar | Yes | Yes |
| Cleaning crew | Coordinates, you usually hire | Hired and managed for you |
| Maintenance and repairs | Rarely | Yes |
| Restocking supplies | Rarely | Yes |
| Vrbo and other platforms | Usually Airbnb only | Usually all platforms |
| Permits, TPT and renewals | Usually you | Usually included |
| Local emergency response | Depends on the person | Yes |
| Best for | Local, hands-on owners | Remote or multi-property owners |
The Fee Math on a Real Scottsdale Home
Percentages are hard to compare in your head, especially when each one is calculated on a different number. So let's run one property through all three.
Say you own a 4-bedroom home in Scottsdale. Based on our market data, that's roughly a ~$475 average nightly rate at ~60% occupancy, or about 219 booked nights a year.
- Nightly revenue: ~$104,000
- Cleaning fees paid by guests (~60 stays at $250): ~$15,000
- Total booking revenue: ~$119,000
Here's what each fee model costs on that same home:
| Fee model | How it's calculated | Annual fee |
|---|---|---|
| Co-host at 15% | 15% of payout (~$115,400 after a 3% Airbnb host fee) | ~$17,300 |
| Typical full-service at 25% | 25% of gross bookings, cleaning included | ~$29,750 |
| Stay AZ at 10-15% | 10-15% of the nightly rate only | ~$10,400 - $15,600 |
The co-host costs more than Stay AZ's top rate here. At 15% of payout they take a cut of the cleaning fees too, and you're still running cleaning, maintenance and compliance yourself.
The base matters as much as the percentage. A fee on the nightly rate leaves cleaning fees out. A fee on gross bookings doesn't. On this home, charging 25% on the ~$15,000 in cleaning fees adds about $3,750 a year.
Want to run your own numbers? Our Airbnb revenue calculator compares self-managing, a co-host, a typical manager and Stay AZ side by side on your property.
The Arizona Part Most Owners Underestimate
Arizona protects your right to run a short-term rental, but cities can regulate how you run it. Both Phoenix and Scottsdale do, and the obligations stack up:
- A city STR permit or license, renewed every year ($250 in both Phoenix and Scottsdale)
- An Arizona TPT license and the tax filings that come with it
- Maricopa County rental registration
- At least $500,000 in liability coverage, or qualifying platform coverage
- An emergency contact who actually responds when the city or a neighbor calls
- Neighbor notification, and in Scottsdale, guest background checks
Each item is simple. They're also ongoing and deadline-driven, and the fines add up. Phoenix can charge up to $1,000 per month for operating without a permit. We break the full rules down in our Phoenix short-term rental laws guide and Scottsdale short-term rental laws guide.
If you hire a co-host, ask directly: who's handling the permit renewal, the TPT filings and the emergency contact? If the answer is "you," budget for your own time.
The emergency contact is the one that catches people. If your co-host lives in another state, or manages 40 listings across three cities, they're not driving over at 11pm when the neighbors complain about noise. Someone local has to.
When a Co-Host Is the Right Call
A co-host makes a lot of sense if:
- You live 20 minutes from the property and don't mind the occasional trip over
- You already have a reliable cleaner and handyman
- You want to stay involved and learn the business
- It's one property, not three
In that setup, a good co-host takes the most annoying part off your plate (messaging at all hours) without paying for services you'd rather do yourself.
When Full-Service Is Worth It
Full-service starts winning when:
- You live out of state or travel a lot
- You own multiple properties, or plan to
- You want listings on Vrbo and direct booking, not just Airbnb
- You don't want to deal with summer maintenance. In Phoenix, an AC or pool issue in July is a same-day problem, not a next-week problem
- You'd rather spend your time on your job, your family or your next deal
The downside is the fee. At 25-35% of gross, full-service eats a big piece of your income, so the manager has to earn it through higher occupancy and rates. If they can't show you how, keep looking.
Where Stay AZ Fits
We built our model to sit in the gap between the two.
You get full-service scope: cleaning, maintenance, restocking, multi-platform listings, dynamic pricing, 24/7 guest messaging, permits and monthly reporting. And you pay 10-15% of the nightly rate, which is closer to co-host pricing than typical manager pricing. No setup fees, month-to-month, and payouts within 24-48 hours of checkout.
One caveat: a low fee only matters if the property performs. So before you pick anyone, us included, ask for real numbers on homes like yours.
You can see how we work in your city on our Scottsdale Airbnb management and Phoenix Airbnb management pages, or compare fees on our pricing page.
Questions to Ask Before You Sign With Anyone
Whether it's a co-host or a manager, get clear answers to these:
- What exactly is the fee calculated on: nightly rate, payout, or gross bookings including cleaning?
- Are there setup fees, maintenance markups or a cut of the cleaning fee?
- Who handles the city permit, TPT license and annual renewals?
- Who is the emergency contact, and where do they live?
- Which platforms will my property be listed on?
- How are repairs approved, and what's the spending limit before you call me?
- What's the contract length, and what does it cost to leave?
- Can you show me revenue on a comparable property you manage?
If someone gets vague on number 1 or number 8, that tells you most of what you need to know.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much does an Airbnb co-host charge in Arizona?
Most co-hosts charge 10-20% of the booking payout. Some charge a flat monthly fee or a per-booking fee instead. Ask whether the percentage includes cleaning fees, since that changes the real cost.
How much does a full-service Airbnb property manager charge in Phoenix or Scottsdale?
Most full-service managers in the Phoenix area charge 20-35% of gross booking revenue. Stay AZ charges 10-15% of the nightly rate, with cleaning fees passed through at cost and no setup fees.
Is a co-host cheaper than a property manager?
Usually on paper, but not always in practice. A co-host's fee covers less, so you're paying separately for cleaning management, maintenance, restocking and compliance, either in money or your own time.
Can a co-host handle my Phoenix or Scottsdale STR permit?
Some do, many don't. Permit renewals, TPT filings and the emergency-contact requirement are ongoing obligations, so confirm in writing who's responsible before you sign.
Can I switch from a co-host to a full-service manager later?
Yes. Your listing, reviews and booking history stay with your Airbnb account. A good manager can take over existing reservations without canceling guests.
Should I self-manage my Airbnb instead?
If you're local, organized and have time, self-managing keeps the most money in your pocket. Just be honest about the hours. Messaging, pricing, turnovers and compliance add up to a part-time job on a busy property.
The Bottom Line
Pick the setup that matches how involved you want to be. Then make every option show you the math on your specific property.
Want that math for your home? Get a free rental analysis and we'll show you realistic revenue and what you'd keep under each fee model.